by Böhm Bawerk
[Title Page and Bibliographic List]: The title page and a comprehensive list of contemporary economic publications from 1895-1898 that will be reviewed in the following essay, including works by Marshall, Dietzel, Stolzmann, Taussig, Wicksell, and others. [Review of Alfred Marshall's Principles of Economics]: Böhm-Bawerk reviews the third edition of Marshall's Principles, praising its systematic depth and elegant form while critiquing its eclectic nature. He argues that Marshall's attempt to synthesize Ricardian cost theory with Jevons's marginal utility succeeds only partially and critiques Marshall's capital theory as a mere variation of Senior's abstinence theory ('waiting') that fails to integrate modern psychological and productive insights into a unified whole. [Critique of Heinrich Dietzel's Value and Cost Theory]: A lengthy critique of Dietzel's 'Theoretische Socialökonomik'. Böhm-Bawerk examines Dietzel's attempt to reconcile classical cost theory with marginal utility, arguing that Dietzel's 'cost' is actually just 'marginal utility of replacement' (Mittelnutzen). He specifically refutes Dietzel's defense of the labor theory of value, pointing out that Dietzel ignores the impact of time and interest on relative prices, which invalidates the claim that labor quantities alone determine value. [Review of Rudolf Stolzmann's Social Category]: Böhm-Bawerk discusses Stolzmann's 'Die sociale Kategorie in der Volkswirtschaftslehre', which emphasizes social power and class struggle over pure economic laws in determining distribution. While sympathetic to the inclusion of social factors, Böhm-Bawerk critiques Stolzmann for falling into the opposite extreme of the classical 'wage fund' theory by suggesting power alone determines value, and he highlights Stolzmann's failure to account for the economic influence of time on capital and value. [Brief Reviews: Taussig, Wicksell, von Buch, Wernicke, and Gottl]: The final section provides short reviews of several authors. Böhm-Bawerk praises Taussig's work on wages and capital as the best existing monograph on the subject. He highlights Wicksell's innovative theory linking interest rates to price levels and the potential for stabilizing money's purchasing power. Finally, he critiques Friedrich Gottl's epistemological skepticism regarding the 'value concept', defending the necessity of value theory despite its current chaotic state.
The title page and a comprehensive list of contemporary economic publications from 1895-1898 that will be reviewed in the following essay, including works by Marshall, Dietzel, Stolzmann, Taussig, Wicksell, and others.
Read full textBöhm-Bawerk reviews the third edition of Marshall's Principles, praising its systematic depth and elegant form while critiquing its eclectic nature. He argues that Marshall's attempt to synthesize Ricardian cost theory with Jevons's marginal utility succeeds only partially and critiques Marshall's capital theory as a mere variation of Senior's abstinence theory ('waiting') that fails to integrate modern psychological and productive insights into a unified whole.
Read full textA lengthy critique of Dietzel's 'Theoretische Socialökonomik'. Böhm-Bawerk examines Dietzel's attempt to reconcile classical cost theory with marginal utility, arguing that Dietzel's 'cost' is actually just 'marginal utility of replacement' (Mittelnutzen). He specifically refutes Dietzel's defense of the labor theory of value, pointing out that Dietzel ignores the impact of time and interest on relative prices, which invalidates the claim that labor quantities alone determine value.
Read full textBöhm-Bawerk discusses Stolzmann's 'Die sociale Kategorie in der Volkswirtschaftslehre', which emphasizes social power and class struggle over pure economic laws in determining distribution. While sympathetic to the inclusion of social factors, Böhm-Bawerk critiques Stolzmann for falling into the opposite extreme of the classical 'wage fund' theory by suggesting power alone determines value, and he highlights Stolzmann's failure to account for the economic influence of time on capital and value.
Read full textThe final section provides short reviews of several authors. Böhm-Bawerk praises Taussig's work on wages and capital as the best existing monograph on the subject. He highlights Wicksell's innovative theory linking interest rates to price levels and the potential for stabilizing money's purchasing power. Finally, he critiques Friedrich Gottl's epistemological skepticism regarding the 'value concept', defending the necessity of value theory despite its current chaotic state.
Read full text